Relationship
 

Why You Should Live With Her First, BEFORE You Marry Her


You would think that couples living together first before getting married would stand a better chance in having a happy and healthy marriage. They get to see how one another acts after so long of living together 24/7. After all, it’s just common sense, isn’t it? But not according to many Ph.D.’s studying marriage and family life. But not that many Ph.D.’s use their commons sense. They’re college educated, but it doesn’t mean much if they don’t use their common sense.

In 2004, a Penn State University study found that living together before marriage is, in fact, linked to higher rates of separation and divorce. Research psychologist Catherine Cohan, a co-author of the study, says the data suggest it has a lot to do with the easy-out situation living together provides, as well as with the type of people who choose to live together before marriage. "Evidence indicates that people who live together have more liberal attitudes toward divorce, are less religious and lead unconventional lifestyles," she says. Often, people who choose to live together do so for convenience, not love. Living together is so strongly associated with divorce, Cohan says, that "if you take two identical twins, with all things being equal, the twin that lived together before marriage is twice as likely to get divorced as the other twin."

Cohan is right on much of what she said, but let’s not say that living together first is a bad idea just because of these kinds of couples who are getting a divorce. I mean, come on.

Back in 2004, a major study and research program was put together by Ph.D.’s from the University of Wisconsin. It showed that a higher divorce rate existed among couples living together before marriage.

Many such studies have been conducted by Ph.D’s, but, here is where they aren’t using any common sense. That stat is probably true, but it’s only because more married couples lived together first, as opposed to the ones who didn’t.

It’s estimated that at least three times more couples live together first. So, for example: You have 9,000 couples who lived together first, where as you have 3,000 couples who didn’t. If you look at the divorces from those 12,000 couples, then of course you are going to get a higher rate of live-ins who got a divorce. It’s just common sense.

Also, could it be that many couples living together are the ones who are more likely to get a divorce anyway? The simple fact of living together is just a coincidence related to divorce, rather than the actual cause.

Another such study came out in 2004 from the University of Denver. The Ph.D’s came up with two reasons why live-ins land up getting a divorce.

1.) Once a couple starts living together, it’s harder to break up the relationship. Either the man or the woman isn’t really that happy and satisfied, but since he or she spent so much time living with their significant other, buying furnishings together, maybe having a child, etc., that person is more reluctant to leave. They have “settled.” They let themselves get in deeper and deeper, and the next thing they know, they are at the alter hoping for the best.

2.) Many feel pressured to get married, because they have been living together for so long. Between the significant other and / or the family, that person relents. It’s usually the men who are pressured. Many cases are when it’s both the man and the woman who are pressured into marriage by their families. Ph.D.’s aren’t much for common sense, but they are correct on these two things.

They are right. Those are the main reasons why live-ins who get married often land up getting a divorce. Living together first isn’t what causes a divorce, it’s the couples themselves who aren’t thinking. Again, let’s don’t throw out the idea of living together first before getting married just because so many couples don’t think before walking down that aisle.

A lot of people don’t really pay attention to what their mate is really like inside, and, if he / she will make a great spouse, for life. They tend to ignore the little things that bother each other. Then, after time, those little things turn into bigger things. Those little things are part of what tears a marriage apart. It’s like a windshield with a tiny little crack in it. If it isn’t fixed, as time goes on that little crack will become bigger, and bigger, and bigger, until finally the windshield has to be thrown out. Just like the marriage. It doesn’t even matter if they aren’t living together, because they are more than likely destined to get a divorce anyway, because, they weren’t meant to be together for the rest of their lives.

An unbelievable amount of live-in couples say that the problems they are having are too insignificant, and that “things will improve” after they get married. Again, let’s not throw out the idea of living together first because of couples like these.

Not one Ph.D. has bothered to mention any of this when they came up with their so-called “research” and them saying that couples should not live together first. As usual, they don’t use common sense.

Having weekend sleep-overs won’t work either because most of the time one or both will be on their good behavior, and, it’s not long enough. A weekend sleep-over is far different from every single day. So, what about those couples who change after they tie the knot? … Yes, there are many, many couples who have lived together first and then later married, only to get a divorce soon after, because, “things changed.” They have only themselves to blame.

Things Change After Getting Married/Testing One Another/Many Couples Compromise By Getting Engaged While Living Together

Perhaps you have heard of the saying, “things change after getting married”? Ph.D’s say that another reason why so many live-in couples get a divorce is because things change after getting married. Just minutes before walking down that aisle or after getting married, the thought of, “we are now going to spend the rest of our lives together” hits one of them or both of them at the same time. It sinks in. But what difference dos it make if they are living together or not? That realization of living together for the rest of their lives is still going to hit them, regardless.

Many, NOT ALL, people actually do change when living together for a certain amount of time. Think about it: Two human beings living together 24/7. Practically all people do change, whether it is for the better or for the worse. That is what living together will conclude for a couple, whether it will turn for the worse or for the better.

Isn’t it better to say, "she wasn't like this before we moved in," than, "she wasn't like this before we married"?

This is where getting engaged while living together is such a great idea. It’s a great test to see if they are REALLY ready for this…FOR LIFE! Call it a “reality check,” if you will.

If he wants to live together first before getting married, and she doesn’t, or vice versa, they can compromise. They can live together for, say, six months, and then get engaged. That way they are one step closer to being more committed. If the partner refuses even that, they aren’t being fair. They aren’t even willing to compromise. Now THAT is a red flag waving, JUST from that. After all, a marriage is about compromising, and if the partner can’t even compromise on that one, well, they better think long and hard before getting married.

Some of you may be saying, “Well, I don’t want to test my girlfriend. A relationship is not about testing one another. It’s about love and commitment.”

One woman said to me, if you go into it as a trial, or to test one another, that's what it will be... and then maybe it is more likely to fail, but if you do things for the right reasons there's no real reason to think it will.

A couple can go into it as a trial / a test, AND for love. You may not realize this, but it is about both. It’s about seeing if the both of them are really ready for a lifetime of commitment, AND it’s about love. Listen, you may be turned off by the word “test” or “trial,” but let’s face it, it IS about testing. It IS about a trial to see if they are right for one another. A couple needs to know if they are really ready for a lifetime commitment. Many couples say to one another, “let’s test one another to see if we are right for one another,” whether it be living together or whatever. There is nothing wrong in that. It is for the right reason.

Living together first is the first test. Getting engaged and setting a date a year or so later to get married to see if “things change” is the second test. Living together while engaged for that year, or whatever the time amount is, is the last test. You can love one another and still see if you are right for one another.

You may be ready, but don’t you want to know if she is REALLY ready for it also? That’s all you need, is a (yet another) divorce down the road. Think about it!

If you aren’t ready for marriage but you want your future girlfriend to move in with you, but she has different views, explain it to her the same way it was explained to you here. If she still isn’t convinced, nothing will. Date other women until you find the one with common sense.

See Perry's other weekly columns on Dating or Sex.

Perry Rose is a syndicated freelance writer for singles on sex, dating and relationships. He is also the author of, All About Men: Another Damn Book For Women About Men. & Women and Sex And Dating, For The Single Man published by Intimacy Books. From first getting dates from complete strangers, to finding that right person to be with, Intimacy Books has interviewed single men and women on what they like and want from one another. The findings were published in Women, Sex and Dating, for the Single Man. Their site is bettersexbetterdating.com



Disclaimer | Privacy Statement
Menstuff® Directory
Menstuff® is a registered trademark of The National Men's Resource Center™
©1996-2005, The National Men's Resource Center